Search
Bluesky

SBGridTV
Button for mobile navigation
Join us

Tale

Pipeline Dreams

Bridget Carragher and Clint Potter

Simons Electron Microscopy Center at the New York Structural Biology Center

Published April 26, 2016

A year ago, Bridget Carragher and Clint Potter’s group broke the so-called three-angstrom barrier for electron microscopy (EM). Prior to their work, so many structures had been solved using EM at 3.4 or 3.5-angstrom resolution that people had started to believe higher resolutions were out of reach with the technology.

"Our group set out to show that EM could do better,” says Carragher, co-Director of the Simons Electron Microscopy Center (SEMC) at the New York Structural Biology Center (NYSBC). “We did things carefully and in a fully automated fashion and got to 2.8 angstroms. That was the first time anyone was able to see water molecules in an EM structure."

Water molecules from an EM structure. Campbell MG, Veesler D, Cheng A, Potter CS, Carragher B. 2.8 A resolution reconstruction of the Thermoplasma acidophilum 20S proteasome using cryo-electron microscopy. eLife (2015).

What was a big deal then has become commonplace now, but only because the EM field is changing so rapidly. Carragher and Clint Potter, the other SEMC co-Director, are among the drivers in the field with their work on EM automation tools such as Leginon and Appion.

Distinguishing between Phe and Tyr starts to become possible. Campbell et al. (2015) eLife.

Their journey in this field began about twenty years ago when they met at the University of Illinois at the Beckman Institute. Carragher was working on EM, and Potter on magnetic resonance imaging. But they were both interested in the automated control of instruments. In the late 1990s, they wrote their first software tools for controlling electron microscopes, among which was an early incarnation of Leginon.

The need for automated tools such as Leginon developed when EM switched from film to digital images. The field of view of digital images is smaller than film, so more need to be taken to get the same amount of information. Instead of hundreds of images, a researcher might need to collect thousands. Graduate students have been known to spend three or four days collecting images even with automation tools at their disposal. “Once you go digital, you have to automate,” says Carragher. “To me there’s no real choice because it’s so tedious.”

In 2001, the Scripps Research Institute recruited Carragher and Potter. Soon after, they received a grant that allowed them to work full-time on automation tools. Their first task was to rewrite Leginon to turn it into professional software that could be maintained and expanded. Before the rewrite, Leginon, says Carragher, “had been hacked together with a bunch of scripts written in Tkl/Tk and some other some bizarre packages.”

They spent a year on the overhaul, this time using Python. During that year, they had nothing. At times, it felt like progress had come to a halt. And in the end, they had the same features that they started with. “Scary times,” says Potter.

Carragher and Potter’s group also developed an automated tool called Appion to process the data produced by Leginon, creating an automation pipeline for single particle EM. Another reason so many images must be taken to get a clear structure with high resolution is that each individual image is grainy since only a few electrons can be bounced off of a sample before destroying it. Those images flow into Appion, which lines them up and processes them.

About ten years ago, Appion was processing data from about 250,000 particles. Today, researchers are using a million particles to get clearer images and a better sense of heterogeneity. “If all the particles are the same, your job is simple,” says Carragher. “But molecular machines found in nature have moving parts. You need to sort that out to tell, for example, if the machine is in a closed or open state.”

Clint Potter and Bridget Carragher, co-directors of the Simons Electron Microscopy Center at the New York Structural Biology Center.

In 2015, Carragher and Potter relocated from Scripps to the New York Structural Biology Center to set up the Simons Electron Microscopy Center using funding from the Simons Foundation. The National Resource for Automated Molecular Microscopy moved to SEMC with them. SEMC is still bringing in new equipment—a new Titan Krios has just been accepted and a second one will be delivered in August 2016—but the Center is up and running and already supporting about a hundred different projects. “We’re serving this enormous group of people and are upgrading this facility to soon — I hope — be one of the best in the world,” says Carragher.

While Leginon and Appion are mature, there is a constant need to support new technology, such as Phase Plates for Cryo-transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and other new devices. Further, the team is working on advancing specimen preparation hardware.

A new automation project is also underway to build an automated pipeline similar to Leginon and Appion, but that spans scales and technologies and can provide a means to look at very large structures, such as a thin slice of a cell. The team envisions integration across scales by integrating images from different sources, such as light microscopes, focused ion beam scanning electron microscopes (FIBSEM), and TEM.

The SEMC team Carragher and Potter have formed includes a group of professional software engineers and staff scientists. This group is critical for achieving continuity. “Nobody wants to have to continuously take over codes from a postdoc,” says Potter. “We’ve been successful with a core group that keeps the software going.”

The SEMC team also includes graduate students and postdocs, who drive the technology by doing challenging biology and also often make major contributions to the technology and software. These young scientists cross-embed themselves at both SEMC and in biology labs to form productive and inventive collaborations. “The biology is driven by a proper biology lab, but the technology is driven here,” says Carragher.

“There’s synergy between the labs,” adds Potter.

“And,” Carragher says, “It lets us tackle some beautifully interesting projects.”

--Elizabeth Dougherty

Other tales

  • Mind and Muscle

    Ryan Hibbs

    Published 28 March 2025

    The Shapes of Energy

    Luke Chao

    Published 12 December 2024

  • Predicting Proteins

    Jens Meiler

    Published 25 November 2024

    Death Metal

    Steven Damo

    Published 28 April 2024

  • Context Matters

    Bing Chen

    Published 30 January 2024

    The Crystal Whisperer

    Sarah Bowman

    Published 29 November 2023

  • Data in Motion

    Nozomi Ando

    Published 29 September 2023

    The Monstrous Maw

    André Hoelz

    Published 28 June 2023

  • Second Takes

    Andrea Thorn

    Published 28 February 2023

    Radical reactions

    Yvain Nicolet

    Published 31 January 2023

  • Floppy Physics

    Eva Nogales

    Published 30 November 2022

    Structure of Equity

    Jamaine Davis

    Published 28 September 2022

  • Life and Death of a Cell

    Evris Gavathiotis

    Published 28 July 2022

    Follow the glow

    Kurt Krause

    Published 29 April 2022

  • Resolution solutions

    Willy Wriggers

    Published 25 February 2022

    Of enzymes and membranes

    Ming Zhou

    Published 28 October 2021

  • Step-by-step

    Gabrielle Rudenko

    Published 26 September 2021

    Moving muscle

    Montserrat Samso

    Published 26 July 2021

  • Particle catcher

    Stefan Raunser

    Published 28 June 2021

    Designer drugs

    Ho Leung Ng

    Published 25 February 2021

  • Right place, right time

    Ernesto Fuentes

    Published 29 January 2021

    Shape-shifting secrets of membranes

    James Hurley

    Published 27 November 2020

  • Enzymatic action

    Cynthia Wolberger

    Published 28 September 2020

    Rules of motion

    Priyamvada Acharya

    Published 31 July 2020

  • Cosmic Squared

    Michael Cianfrocco

    Published 27 June 2020

    Kaps are Cool

    Yuh Min Chook

    Published 28 April 2020

  • Spiraling into focus

    Carsten Sachse

    Published 29 March 2020

    Seeing cilia

    Alan Brown

    Published 27 February 2020

  • For the Love of EM

    Guy Schoehn

    Published 27 January 2020

    Protein Puddles

    Michael Rosen

    Published 16 December 2019

  • Changing channels

    Daniel Minor Jr.

    Published 27 September 2019

    Listening Tips

    Marcos Sotomayor

    Published 30 July 2019

  • Beyond Cool

    Published 31 May 2019

    Hao Wu

    A Higher Order

    Published 30 May 2019

  • Aye Aye Captain

    Alexandre Bonvin

    Published 29 April 2019

    The PARP Family Family

    John Pascal

    Published 28 February 2019

  • Frame by frame

    Nikolaus Grigorieff

    Published 28 January 2019

    Predicting Success

    Bil Clemons

    Published 18 December 2018

  • Curiouser and Curiouser

    Ramaswamy Subramanian

    Published 27 November 2018

    Rely on This

    Sjors Scheres

    Published 26 October 2018

  • Proteins out of bounds

    Gerhard Wagner

    Published 27 September 2018

    Hiding in plain sight

    Gaya Amarasinghe

    Published 27 July 2018

  • Jumping Genes

    Orsolya Barabas

    Published 27 June 2018

    Data Whisperer

    Karolin Luger

    Published 30 May 2018

  • Flipping the Switch

    Jacqueline Cherfils

    Published 27 April 2018

    Tooling Around

    Andrew Kruse

    Published 29 March 2018

  • Comings and Goings

    Tom Rapoport, Ph.D.

    Published 23 February 2018

    Transcriptional Rhythm

    Seth Darst

    Published 27 January 2018

  • The Language of Gene Regulation

    Daniel Panne

    Published 21 November 2017

    Not Your Average Protein

    James Fraser

    Published 23 October 2017

  • Message Received

    Sebastien Granier

    Published 24 August 2017

    Resistance is Futile

    Celia Schiffer

    Published 28 July 2017

  • Twist of Fate

    Leemor Joshua-Tor

    Published 28 June 2017

    Drug Designer

    John Buolamwini

    Published 30 May 2017

  • Mathematically Minded

    James Holton

    Published 28 April 2017

    Garbage Out

    Kay Diederichs

    Published 30 March 2017

  • Fixer Upper

    Brandt Eichman

    Published 27 February 2017

    Mobilizers

    Phoebe Rice

    Published 31 January 2017

  • Escape Artist

    Katya Heldwein

    Published 19 December 2016

    Nature’s Confectioner

    Jochen Zimmer

    Published 29 November 2016

  • State of Fusion

    Jason McLellan

    Published 27 October 2016

    Here Be Dragons

    Brian Fox

    Published 28 September 2016

  • SBGrid Assumes Ownership of PyMOLWiki

    Published 15 September 2016

    Pharm Team

    Oleg Tsodikov

    Published 24 August 2016

  • Spiro-Gyra

    Alejandro Buschiazzo

    Published 27 July 2016

    Turning the DIALS

    Nicholas Sauter

    Published 29 June 2016

  • Pipeline Dreams

    Bridget Carragher and Clint Potter

    Published 26 April 2016

    U-Store-It

    The SBGrid Data Bank provides an affordable and sustainable way to preserve and share structural biology data

    Published 28 March 2016

  • Big Questions, Big Answers

    Jennifer Doudna

    Published 22 February 2016

    Not a Structural Biologist

    Enrico Di Cera

    Published 17 December 2015

  • Divide and Conquer

    Kevin Corbett

    Published 19 November 2015

    Computing Cellular Clockworks

    Klaus Schulten

    Published 23 October 2015

  • Trans-Plant

    Gang Dong

    Published 26 September 2015

    Keep on Moving

    James Berger

    Published 23 August 2015

  • Totally Tubular

    Antonina Roll-Mecak

    Published 27 July 2015

    From Disorder, Function

    Julie Forman-Kay

    Published 29 June 2015

  • Into Alignment

    Geoff Barton

    Published 27 May 2015

    Two Labs, Many Methods

    Michael Sattler

    Published 28 April 2015

  • Picture This

    Georgios Skiniotis

    Published 20 March 2015

    Intron Intrigue

    Navtej Toor

    Published 20 February 2015

  • Cut and Paste

    Martin Jinek

    Published 28 January 2015

    Basics and Beyond

    Qing Fan

    Published 18 December 2014

  • Bloodletting and Other Studies

    Pedro José Barbosa Pereira

    Published 25 November 2014

    Wire Models, Wired

    A brief history of UCSF Chimera

    Published 29 October 2014

  • In Search of…New Drugs

    Doug Daniels

    Published 30 September 2014

    An Affinity for Affinity…and Corals

    John C. Williams

    Published 29 August 2014

  • Pete Meyer, Ph.D.

    Research Computing Specialist

    Published 22 August 2014

    Justin O'Connor

    Sr. System Administrator

    Published 20 August 2014

  • Carol Herre

    Software Release Engineer

    Published 15 August 2014

    Elizabeth Dougherty

    Science Writer

    Published 13 August 2014

  • Andrew Morin, Ph.D.

    Policy Research Fellow

    Published 11 August 2014

    Jason Key, Ph.D.

    Associate Director of Technology and Innovation

    Published 8 August 2014

  • Piotr Sliz, Ph.D.

    Principal Investigator, SBGrid

    Published 1 August 2014

    New Kid on the Block

    James Chen

    Published 29 July 2014

  • Membrane Master

    Tamir Gonen

    Published 30 June 2014

    The Natural Bridge

    Piotr Sliz

    Published 13 June 2014

  • Surprise, Surprise

    Catherine Drennan

    Published 26 April 2014

    Gone Viral

    Olve Peersen

    Published 20 March 2014

  • All Who Wander Are Not Lost

    Frank Delaglio

    Published 24 February 2014

    The Raw and the Cooked

    Graeme Winter

    Published 24 January 2014

  • Vacc-elerator

    Peter Kwong

    Published 17 December 2013

    Structural Storyteller

    Karin Reinisch

    Published 15 November 2013

  • The Fixer

    Jane Richardson

    Published 28 October 2013

    Inside the Box

    Mishtu Dey

    Published 17 September 2013

  • Sensing a Change

    Brian Crane

    Published 16 August 2013

    Towards Personalized Oncology

    Mark Lemmon

    Published 16 July 2013

  • Brush with Fame

    Yizhi Jane Tao

    Published 14 June 2013

    Toxic Avenger

    Borden Lacy

    Published 21 May 2013

  • Pushing the Boundaries

    Stephen Harrison

    Published 22 April 2013

    Strength in Numbers

    Joseph Ho

    Published 18 March 2013

  • One Lab, Many Methods

    Wesley Sundquist

    Published 12 February 2013

    Unplanned Pioneer

    Tim Stevens

    Published 15 January 2013

  • From Actin to Action

    Emil Pai

    Published 11 January 2013

    Unstructured

    A Brief History of CCP4

    Published 12 December 2012

  • Stop, Collaborate and Listen

    Eleanor Dodson

    Published 5 November 2012

    X-PLORer

    Axel Brunger

    Published 1 October 2012

  • Share the Wealth

    Zbyszek Otwinowski

    Published 22 August 2012

    Unraveling RNA

    Anna Pyle

    Published 18 July 2012

  • Sharper Image

    Pawel Penczek and SPARX

    Published 4 June 2012

    Creative Copy Cat

    Pamela Bjorkman

    Published 25 April 2012

  • Charm and Diplomacy

    Gerard Kleywegt

    Published 7 March 2012

    From Curiosity to Cure

    Marc Kvansakul

    Published 13 December 2011

  • The Lure of the Sandbox

    Paul Emsley and Coot

    Published 15 October 2011

    Springsteen, Tolkien, Protein

    Alwyn Jones and Frodo

    Published 17 June 2011

  • Structures Solved Simply

    Paul Adams and Tom Terwilliger on Phenix

    Published 2 June 2011

    Escape from the Darkroom

    Wolfgang Kabsch and XDS

    Published 19 May 2011

  • Playing the Odds

    Randy Read and Phaser

    Published 19 May 2011

    Better, Faster, Stronger, More

    Victor Lamzin and ARP/wARP

    Published 17 May 2011

  • Crystallography for Kids

    Lynne Howell

    Published 17 May 2011

    Side-Track to Success

    Ning Zheng

    Published 13 May 2011

Scroll